I had a vr4 get hit and totaled (while it was parked) back in 05 or 06. Initially insurance wanted to give me standard 6th gen price. I think it was about $900, give or take. Of course i balked at such a notion, and explained a little about the car, and how it's not just some 91 galant. They had me get some pricing around the US and wound up giving me a check for $4300.
I had a guy back into 1411 in 04 at a gas station. He didnt want to get insurance involved so he had me get two quotes. For a cracked left headlight lens, slightly bent lip on the hood and scratched bumper he wound up cutting me a check for $1600 and change.
I replaced the bumper and hood with spares i had on hand, replaced the headlights with a set of 93's from PnP, and spent the money on bills and whatever else.
I wouldn't be surprised to see an estimate for repairs on this little mishap to be in the neighborhood of 1500. They may want to total it, unless you have some discussion with the insurance company and explain that it's not just some shitbox base or LS Galant.