Quoting rexwagon1909:
Thanks man!! I'm def OCD lol. I am going to have to get one of those tumblers, although I will say leave bolts overnight in a bath of Eastwoods rust dissolver and they come out like new. Just make sure to put a little rust proof primer on the bolt top afterwards and they come out great. Just about every bolt from front end to the rear end has been treated lol
Those bolts came out really well even without using a tumbler.
With results as good as that you obviously don't need to change, but another rust remover I tried out recently that works really well is "Metal Rescue". I was a bit skeptical at first, and the fact that the first batch I picked up turned out to be faulty didn't help! However customer service was top notch, the company replaced the entire batch and the results were awesome. I was thinking of posting up some before and after pics myself. Best part is that it has completely removed all rust from every part that I've thrown at it within just 3 hours!