Some rapid fire research I thought I'd share...
Pulled up the Cars for Sale section. Opened a spreadsheet. Started typing.
YEAR, ASKING PRICE, STATE, NOTES
TOTAL LISTINGS HERE SINCE JANUARY 1, 2010: 54
NUMBER OF SHELLS/PART-OUTs: 8
NUMBER SHOWING SOLD (that still showed price): 5
Average selling price (again, from those I could find which still had a price in them): $3330
Average listing price of rollers, shells, broken dreams: $937.50
Average listing price otherwise: $4493.88 (including outliers)
Outliers*: 6 with an average listing price of $8033.33
Average listing price without outliers*: $3887.11
*If the average listing price, without the premium-priced specimens, was almost $4000, I weighted any listing greater than 150% of that figure as an outlier. This meant that I included $6000 listings, but did NOT include the 6 cars listed in the range of $6500-$11,000.
How am I going to use this information? (Bookmarked this thread yet?)
1. When the insurance comes back and says my car is only worth $1000, I'll advise them that $1000 will barely cover the price of a gutted, rolling shell being sold for parts. My car is 100% complete and I will be continuing to drive it until the time I pull it into the garage to do the repairs.
2. I'm going to fight for $4500 replacement cost and expect to negotiate down to $4000.
I do not accept their NADA, KBB, Edmunds, Autosource valuations, as they are incapable of accurately determining the value of specialty vehicles in numbers less than 2000 units which are, perhaps 99% of the time, sold between private parties through listings on enthusiast sites. They can track dealership sales, Autotrader listings, whatever they want. I'm not buying it and it will cost them more, the longer they drag this out.
The law provides property owners who incur a loss, through no fault of their own, to be reimbursed the lesser of the cost of repairs or replacement (cash) value. We'll see about that...