brianawd went from a ported Mitsu manifold (can't remember which one) to a tubular DNP and noticed a big difference. Zach, who used to work at English dynod his FP and swapped it out for a tubular DNP, hoping it would make better numbers (this was on a 450awhp/500+awtq 16g DSM), the numbers were very close, enough to say that the changing condition attributed to the different numbers, it was within a few horsepower.
The FP holds heat very well, and thus sending hotter exhaust through the turbine which makes a big difference (another example of this is with retarded timing, the turbo spools faster). The tubular manifolds have longer and more equal length runners which work better for our application, but they dissipate heat too quickly and the gas cools off more so than the cast manifolds.
It ultimately ends up being a wash, but with the durability of the the cast manifold, it is enough reason to stick with a cast manifold until I'm ready for a T3 or T4 setup.
I have ~35k miles on my FP manifold and have not had a single issue with it. No rust, no cracks, although the discoloration is less than desirable.