Mark,
Trust me man, I live with winter for nine months every year. Everyday I go thru the exact conditions you're gonna see going skiing just getting back to the ranch
Since your primary concern is getting it to the closed loop temp, a lil carboard kinda only sorta works.
The cooling system works on the differential between the ambient temp and cooling system temperatures. The stat trys to maintain it's set temp, but when it's brutal cold outside, any airflow will drop the temp to the very bottom of the stat's range. If you block it well enough to prevent the thing from cooling to the bottom of the stats range under low load and highway speed, you're gonna get it all hot and bothered if you put any heat into it with a little spirited driving.
It has been my personal experience on these cars that if you block the radiator with cardboard, you'd better not boost much climbing hills, as sooner or later, you'll get it too hot having fun. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/devil.gif You'll end up popping something in the cooling system, most likely one of the little cooling hoses to the t-body/oil cooler, or the radiator itself.
In addition, you will shorten your alternators life considerably blocking it's airflow, and then asking it to run the fans 24/7 climbng hills... crazy heat comes off the downpipe under boost. Even in the winter, mitsubishi alternators are prone to failure.
Even if you don't have any mechanical failures, as you've already found, you're still going to have issues getting the system up to temp going back downhill as the deck is stacked against you. The ecu turns the injectors off against a closed throttle, and so you're not putting any heat into the engine.
Trust me, get the hot stat, plug the bleeder dingus, and you'll be good to go.
It works for me, and I gaurandamntee you I'm harder on my sh*t in winter than anyone here. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif
**Note, this advice only really applies to Mark, Karter, and a few others that will see artic conditions and spirited driving for extended periods climbing mountains in the winter. Flatlanders can get away with cardboard just fine. Just pay attention to the temp gauge, and make note that when the fans start running all the time, you've got too much airflow blocked for the conditions.
If you do use cardboard, follow Atc250r's excellent advice and use glossy cardboard, as it'll stand up to wet conditions better. I usually make a good one once, out of regular thick cardboard, and then cover it with clear packing tape. I've used the same piece for my truck for five years.